My Big Fat Nerdy Star Wars PostFirst of all, my new ranking of the moviesEpisodes III and V on top --> Episodes II, IV, and VI all in the same ballpark - a significant level down from the top (the new trilogy definitely elevated VI and lowered IV for me) --> Episode I well behind the rest of the pack
Some mysteries which were left unsolved by the new trilogy- What was the point of Episode I other than to spend two hours explaining that 1) Palpatine manufactured the attack on Naboo to get himself the sympathy vote so he'd be elected as Chancellor of the Senate; and that 2) Anakin had no father. It took me 20 seconds to write that sentence. How did Lucas come up with another 1:59:40 of crap for that movie. Am I forgetting something?
- The "Sifo-Dyas" reference from Episode II... what the hell was up with that? We never heard the name once in Episode III despite the implication from Episode II that it was a big deal. Was it actually Sifo-Dyas that ordered the Clone Army? Or if not, was it a Sith impersonating Sifo-Dyas after Sifo-Dyas had been killed? And if it was a Sith, was it Sidious, Dooku, or Darth Maul?
- Was it a Sith that caused Anakin to be conceived? A couple of us thought of this after the movie when reflecting on Sidious's chatter about the Sith Lord with such knowledge of the Force that he could alter midichlorians and create life. If it was a Sith, did Sidious's former master "father" Anakin before (or after) Sidious killed him? Or did Sidious himself "father" Anakin? The latter would mean that Sidious lied to Anakin later when he said that special knowledge of the Force had been lost.
Some Episode III thoughts- I loved almost everything about this movie. But I guess I'll get two gripes out of the way up front:
There were two or three Anakin/Padme scenes that were on par, painwise, with watching a cute dog get run over by a car in slow motion. This was no shocker, but it was still annoying. On the other hand, Jar-Jar was reduced to a cameo, so I give Lucas props there.
The blue-screening of Anakin and Obi-Wan onto the lava scene during the climactic end duel wasn't as seamless as the rest of the movie. It just didn't look quite right. Though to Lucas's credit, I think it looked like a pretty hard effect to even attempt. I read somewhere that they were integrating live action, computer animation, and actual volcano & lava footage which sounds pretty tricky.
- There were also two significant details lost on anyone that did not see the animated "Episode 2.5" Clone Wars series: 1) Palpatine had a hand in the elevation of Anakin from padawan to Jedi Knight - movie watchers are only clued in that he became a regular Jedi at some point between Episodes II and III; and 2) General Grievous really was a badass until Mace Windu finally got a good shot in on him at the end of the animated series. Movie-goers would have no idea why Grievous was coughing and sickly when the action starts. He killed at least a few Jedis in the animated series, but after his injury, he never added another light saber to his collection.
- I loved some of the symmetries and recalling of other Star Wars moments. For example, Sidious and Vader were both disfigured and beaten in one-on-one combat with Jedis before each swooped in to save the other's life. And even better was the scene towards the beginning when Sidious commanded Anakin to kill the defeated Count Dooku en route to Anakin's dark apprenticeship. This fit perfectly with the scene in Episode VI where Sidious tries to bring about the same result with Luke and a defeated Darth Vader. And there was also a "Search your feelings, you know it be true" line thrown in by someone at some point along the way which echoed Vader's line to Luke from Episode V.
- And despite more awful dialogue between the two, there were also two very good Padme/Anakin scenes in this movie -- the megapivotal decision moment for Anakin where they're looking out across the amazing cityscape at each other, at sunset, with a perfectly haunting (non-John Williams) theme playing in the background. And there's of course that final scene where Anakin actually chokes her, Vader-style.
- I was also pleased with how Lucas managed to off Mace Windu with dignity. Yes, he gets killed, but he also gets the distinction of being the only person to overcome Sidious in a showdown in either trilogy. It just sucks in general to be a Jedi up against Darth Sidious plus a soon-to-be Darth Vader. And while on the subject of Palpatine/Darth Sidious, I'd like to say that Ian McDiarmid fucking OWNED this movie. What a great bad guy character and what a great acting job!
- Sidious wildly hurling Senate boxes down at Yoda brought a cool symbolism with it. The Senate had become the playhouse of the Sith. Sidious was literally trying to kill Yoda with symbols of the old democracy. Have I mentioned that I love this bad guy character?
- I've heard some people question the purpose of the Empire's operations on the lava planet and basically say the planet was a gratuitous effects vehicle. But right from my first viewing, I was fairly certain that the sci-fi purpose of that stuff was to get the huge amount of raw material needed to build a Death Star over the 20 years between Episodes III and IV. I figured that was the reason for those little flying droids with the buckets to scoop up the stuff. So maybe it was actually molten metal, not rock? Or am I reading way too far into it??
- The Anakin-Flame-Broiled scene: YES! AWESOME
- In general, Lucas did an amazing job keeping you interested despite the fact that any fan knew that: Padme would give birth to twins; Dooku, Grievous, Mace Windu, and Padme would die; Anakin would turn to the dark side; and Obi-Wan and Yoda would go into hiding at the end. That kind of viewer pre-knowledge is a pretty big handicap to overcome. The focus on how Anakin was turned to the dark side was well executed. And the fact that Anakin did not immediately sell out for the dark side and instead actually revealed the identity of Sidious to the Jedis was unexpected. The role of the storm troopers as automatons blindly loyal to the Chancellor was perfect... "Order 66" was sweet. Getting to see Yoda emotionally crushed in the end was so jarring after growing up on Star Wars and thinking that Yoda was untouchable and that nothing (other than old-age) could mess with him. A kick-ass movie in my book.
Thoughts on integration with the original trilogy- I guess for starters, you have to view Episode IV in the same light as a movie like 2001: they're films you must first appreciate for their startling technical movie-making breakthroughs in the contexts of 1968 or 1977. I say this because after popping in the DVD shortly after watching Episode III, it really is a bit of a let down. There's a slower pace and about 5000% less light-saber eye candy.
That said, it still made all the detail-filling of Episode III fun to track. There were plenty of obvious ones like the glimpse of the cool Death Star skeleton. And then there were also plenty of subtle ones such as when Obi-Wan quickly picked up stumpy Anakin's light saber at the very end. I only caught this during my second viewing of the movie -- this scene was of course necessary for Luke to be able receive the light saber from Obi-Wan in the next movie. Another cute one was when Lucas appears to show us a brief glimpse of a young Grand Moff Tarkin during the Death Star skeleton scene. And best of all, I think I heard Jimmy Smits say "Captain Antilles" at some point which I'm sure was meant to be a reference to Wedge's father.
- I'm also happy about the fact that Anakin was so pissed off about not being awarded the rank of "Master" from the Jedi Council. This definitely adds to the Vader/Obi-Wan exchange from Episode IV where Vader says something like "The circle is complete... but I am the master now." So you could interpret that he was still pissed off 20 years later about the whole thing. And then Obi-Wan has a good putdown line like "only a master of evil."
- Some of the space ships we saw in Episode III also matched up nicely with the Episode IV stuff. There were early model X-Wings and Star Destroyers and a throwback Emperor's Shuttle. And better yet was the bridge scene with the Emperor and Vader from inside a Star Destroyer and the Jimmy Smits ship from the end of the movie which were both dead-on replications of original trilogy interiors.
- Finally, there was Qui-Gon's ghost returning via the Force. He teaches Yoda who then teaches Obi-Wan about communing after death and joining the Force. This was a little hokey, no doubt, but I thought it was also a pretty clever way to explain why Obi-Wan could later communicate with Luke after death and why Obi-Wan and Yoda's bodies disappeared when they died in the original trilogy while the bodies of dead Jedis in the new trilogy did not. It also better explains why Vader, a former Jedi himself, was so perplexed when he killed Obi-Wan and the body vanished.
[end nerd mode]